Join Chalkbeat Chicago’s free each day publication to maintain up with the most recent training information.
Mayor Brandon Johnson’s administration floated a plan for Chicago Public Colleges to borrow as much as $300 million to assist pay for elevated wage and a few pension prices subsequent yr, Chalkbeat has realized.
However CPS management balked on the thought — calling it a “fictional or phantom income supply” — and pushed again on Metropolis Corridor’s request, in keeping with an inside memo obtained by Chalkbeat and a number of sources aware of their discussions.
The inner CPS memo, dated July 8, outlines the dangers of borrowing to pay for hypothetical 4% raises for lecturers and principals and canopy a $175 million pension cost that was shifted to the varsity district by former Mayor Lori Lightfoot.
If the district coated these raises and pension funds, the district’s projected deficit would develop to $933 million for subsequent fiscal yr, the memo mentioned. Borrowing $300 million to pay for bills this yr “solely shifts the issue” to the next yr and can imply increased prices to repay debt down the road, the memo mentioned.
The mayor’s workplace didn’t touch upon the suggestion to borrow cash, however mentioned in an announcement that the district has restricted choices to shut its finances hole. It mentioned the mayor helps the “cost-saving measures and operational efficiencies,” however isn’t supportive of cuts to important workers and is having conversations to unravel the district’s monetary challenges.
Mortgage suggestion comes amid CPS finances challenges
CPS had roughly $9.3 billion in excellent debt as of June 1, and its debt-service obligations already divert a whole lot of thousands and thousands of {dollars} away from school rooms yearly. Officers included greater than $800 million in debt funds within the district’s proposed $9.9 billion working finances introduced earlier this week. The proposal would shut a $505 million shortfall — pushed largely by the finish of federal COVID cash — via cuts on the district’s central workplace and staffing, as effectively via restructuring some present debt and federal grants.
The proposed finances doesn’t embody any new borrowing, or issue within the prices of latest bargaining agreements which can be being negotiated now, together with with the Chicago Academics Union.
Johnson blasted that finances proposal Thursday. In an announcement Friday, his workplace mentioned he supported how the district proposed to shut its finances deficit and known as the brand new faculty funding components “promising,” however mentioned there may be “nonetheless extra work to be finished.”
The lecturers union known as the finances proposal “an act of make-believe.” The Board of Training is anticipated to vote on the finances proposal later this month.
Johnson, the lecturers union, and CPS had unsuccessfully pushed state lawmakers to supply more cash to the district as a way to assist shut its funding hole. Whereas state funding for Chicago faculties has elevated since 2017, CPS would wish one other $1 billion to be thought of “adequately funded” beneath the state’s faculty funding components. Nevertheless, the interior memo notes that previously, CPS used deficit spending “as a technique to extend stress on the state for extra state funding, nevertheless it by no means labored.”
A district spokesperson declined to touch upon the mortgage suggestion, besides to say that CPS has not taken on a mortgage to stability its finances.
“We are going to proceed to collaborate with Metropolis leaders, our labor, civic and group companions, to search out options to the long-standing public training funding challenges so we will greatest assist our college students’ continued success,” CPS spokesperson Mary Ann Fergus mentioned in an announcement.
The union additionally took challenge this week with the district’s total proposed finances.
“As we evaluation this finances proposal, it’s clear that CPS management has didn’t take steps to ensure our college students and their households what they should dream, obtain and thrive,” CTU President Stacy Davis Gates mentioned in an announcement Wednesday.
Earlier within the month, the union decried layoffs of at the very least 330 of its members amid a brand new strategy to how the district funds its faculties. These members will seemingly be rehired at different faculties, however the layoffs brought about disruption for lecturers and faculty communities, CTU mentioned.
The union didn’t remark particularly on the problem of a mortgage. In an announcement, Vice President Jackson Potter mentioned CPS CEO Pedro Martinez is “shirking his accountability” to construct a finances that gives a high quality training, particularly for households on the South and West sides, and the union expects CPS, town, and state “to search out actual options and work collectively to craft a finances that gives stability, fairness, and high quality.”
The principals union mentioned in an announcement that Metropolis Corridor’s suggestion for a mortgage “isn’t the reply.” The union additionally expressed concern that officers are estimating an $8 million value for its contract, on condition that negotiations are ongoing.
The union mentioned that the present finances is partly pushed by the burden of earlier borrowing, and that finances obligations “shouldn’t be happy on the backs of our college students.”
Previous pension value shift at heart of disagreement over borrowing
Metropolis Corridor’s suggestion that CPS borrow cash is tied partly to pension funds for the retirement of CPS workers that aren’t lecturers via the Municipal Workers’ Annuity and Profit Fund of Chicago, in keeping with the July 8 CPS memo. The town used to cowl this value via its personal finances, however Lightfoot started shifting that value to CPS, beginning with a $60 million cost in 2020, a transfer that Johnson and the CTU criticized on the time.
Now, beneath Johnson as mayor, Metropolis Corridor needs CPS to cowl $175 million of the pension funds, the memo says. That’s the identical quantity the district contributed final yr.
Along with the pension funds, the instructed borrowing would assist cowl $120 million in elevated prices related to a brand new Chicago Academics Union contract. One other $8 million can be for prices associated to the primary contract beneath Chicago’s new principals union, the memo says. Each contracts are nonetheless in negotiations.
In all, beneath Metropolis Corridor’s proposed mortgage plan, the district would tackle $284 million in new bills to be coated with borrowed cash that will be paid off over the following 20 years.
Within the memo, which analyzes Metropolis Corridor’s proposal for the Board of Training, district officers warned that whereas borrowing cash might resolve a direct drawback, the district continues to be projecting deficits in future fiscal years.
Taking out a mortgage might additionally injury the district’s already low bond rankings, the memo mentioned. Even with current ranking upgrades, CPS continues to be “the most important junk bond issuer in america,” in keeping with the memo.
A low bond ranking is just like a low credit score rating. It makes it dearer for the district to borrow cash to fund its capital finances, which is used to enhance or construct new faculty services, the memo mentioned.
“This may very well be regarded as placing your bank card funds that you could now not afford in your mortgage funds,” the memo mentioned. “It permits money to be freed up for different bills, nevertheless it seeds a pricey legacy of future quantities of bigger debt to be paid again and it doesn’t resolve the problem of being fiscally accountable.”
The memo is correct concerning the impression of taking out a mortgage to cowl working prices, mentioned Joe Ferguson, president of the Civic Federation, a nonpartisan authorities watchdog group, who can be Chicago’s former inspector normal.
Moreover, it’s not clear how CPS would stability its finances in future years, given the elevated borrowing prices, Ferguson famous. The kind of mortgage described within the memo is akin to a payday mortgage, the place rates of interest are very excessive, he mentioned.
“One of many ironies right here is that, CPS — lengthy derided and criticized for irresponsible practices — on this second is endeavoring to be the accountable actor,” by closing its deficit via varied cuts and debt restructuring, Ferguson mentioned.
Chicago Public Colleges has an extended historical past of borrowing to pay bills, together with dangerous bond offers throughout the 2000s that saddled the system with extra long-term debt. The Chicago Academics Union grew to become a vocal critic of the district’s borrowing practices after the Chicago Tribune’s reporting on the problem in 2014.
When the district confronted deficits between the 2014 and 2017 fiscal years, CPS borrowed cash to cowl working bills since administrations on the time didn’t need to reduce prices. The district owes $3.7 billion in principal and curiosity funds for that borrowing, the memo mentioned.
The not too long ago proposed finances is about 75% bigger than a decade in the past, when CPS had a $5.6 billion working finances. Johnson has lobbied board members to approve the mortgage plan, however the board “is remaining agency of their pushback,” in keeping with one supply with data of the conversations.
Chalkbeat Chicago Bureau Chief Becky Vevea contributed.
Reema Amin is a reporter masking Chicago Public Colleges. Contact Reema at ramin@chalkbeat.org.
